Friday, 5 August 2016

Do you want to be a saint?



Sometimes religious life is characterised by an odd sort of tension. The world of piety, which aims at a precise, quantifiable perfection and the world of holistic religiosity, which rejects detailed examinations of anything as being overly pedantic. The holistic religious person enters a neighbourhood such as Me'ah She'arim and leaves with bewilderment and a degree of disgust. The pious person feels the same way about going to Tel Aviv or Netanya.

When I was in Israel a few months ago, I observed what I consider to be the difference between a religious society and a pious society. Israel is a secular state, right? Well it isn't, really; even in Tel Aviv, that sin city. Religion plays its part in every aspect of life in Israel, sometimes more subtly than explicitly. It cultivates a particular mindset about the world and has God at its centre in some form or another. But, in a sense, it remains 'natural'. It hovers around regular life but does not necessarily infuse its every aspect by shoving it in your face. 

I don't think this has nothing to do with being 'Frum'. Frumkeit is often derided for being superficial and insincere. I will not go down this road as it seems very unfair to question other people's motives. Rather what I will point out is that groups of people who try to become 'frum' are concerned almost exclusively with piety, the quantifiable aspect of religiosity. Laws, intricate details of Shabbat observance, pots and pans, tzniut, what I should and shouldn't do. Even the perfection of particular traits. 

This is the road to saintliness. From what I have studied, the undercurrent of kabbalistic piety is that religiosity can be quantified. Even a perusal of the mussar literature that remain the works that are cited in terms of Jewish morals and ethics are quite determined to see character development as a systematic, quantifiable entity. There is a road, a path and a clear direction, even if it is difficult to achieve.

But you have to ask the question at one point, do I want to be a saint? No, not some guy who gives afterlife credits via spare body parts but rather do I really want to be perfect in this sense? In a particular, pedantic sense - do I aspire to scrutinise every action to achieve perfection? The honest answer is probably no. 

Why? Because I have never looked up to saint-like behaviour. I see how aspirations towards this way of life leads to boring, clone-like societies dominated by a certain insecurity, fear and looking over the shoulder. I can't bring myself to want that. It was the sort of irritated feeling I got when looking at a shidduch form. 

What I wrote: Keep Shabbat, tick, keep kosher, tick, cover hair tick. 

What I thought: Shut up and go away. Just go away. 

I think that piety is confusing as an aspiration because too often it seems rather irritating and pedantic. And by quantifying everything, the joy and spontaneity associated with mitzvah observance can quickly evaporate. Stop thinking about things that should not be overthought. Especially in the realm of interpersonal behaviour, reading about how to behave will often have the opposite effect.  

 And to many, piety is synonymous with being religious, and this can be extremely off-putting. A nicely drawn ladder of self-improvement seems kind of self-righteous and self-contained. It just isn't relaxed, calm or particularly easy to admire. 

Relationships are all about the details? Erm. Not really. If I was examined on every tiny thing I did all the time I would go bananas. Details have their moments.  

I always think of this one person who is widely admired for mastering his instincts and never getting too emotional but I always thought of him as a robot who has lost touch with fellow human beings. Saintliness might be for some but this-worldly toil and acceptance of fallibility does it much more for others because those people get life as it is.

Does this conflict with religious belief and observance? I think it very much depends what we mean by religious and it often plays out in my head as a battle between myself circa 2010 and myself now. And perhaps therein lies a conflict within how we understand religion itself. Should the direction of religious life be serene, clearly-marked and harmonious like a David Gower cover drive or should it be gritty, tough and fighting like an Alan Border at the crease? 

Steve Waugh, one of the most Australian captains in Test history, spoke of his need to evolve from a dashing young strokemaker to a gritty fighter who would not give away his wicket at all costs. Sometimes you need to figure out the time and place for mr. pious to come to the crease and when to tell him to go away.  

David Gower: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qLk3GudLFpg 
Alan Border: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=65xgEnd6LSY




Thursday, 28 July 2016

Reflections on turning 25: A sermon that can't be delivered.




Last week I turned 25. I had originally written a long post which began like this:

'Traditionally, I've always hated birthdays. It always triggers something of an 'existential' crisis ( a favourite crisis of the modern orthodox). What is the point of it all? Where on earth am I going and what have I achieved? Time can be a cruel thing. It lurks unnoticed and one day you look behind you and wonder where it has gone. And before you lies the chasm between what you thought you could be, should be and are.' 


But then I've deleted the rest. There is a time and place for cynical ranting and it seems rather ungracious to do so when by any standards I have a wonderful life. Also, because intense moods pass and leave with you a slight sense of shame. But the date does lurk every year and poses a challenge: Justify.  25 also seems significant: No longer a child. Nearer to 30 than 20. Hmmm.


Perhaps based on the optimism of teenage years, or the years I spent in organisations promoting 'meaningful' as opposed to 'meaningless' existence, I have struggled and will continue to struggle with the idea of making a mark on the world. Whatever I do I can't escape the fact that most of all, I want to be significant and original. 


Yes, to all Pokemon fans, I want to be very best that no-one ever was. And I'm beginning to understand things I never used to. The pursuit of wealth, for example. Mad, exhausted sleep-deprived city stooges? I get it. Perhaps it is wealth they pursue but perhaps it is also the fact that money is quantifiable. Promotions are quantifiable. Progress and self-actualisation is quite easy to visualise in the drab grey walls they occupy. They can be the best.  


It all seems rather selfish, I must admit.

In fact, sometimes I think PHD theses are trying to project the individual's desire for uniqueness into an obscure study of something fairly irrelevant. 


I know from experience that there is nothing worse than reading something which is very similar to something you have thought on a particular area. Argh, must find a small detail to nitpick and then crush: Yes, x was clearly influenced by outdated structuralist/ historicist perspectives! Ha! I can breath as I send the buffoon back to his lair and I am king again.

I had the same problem with finishing my Masters dissertation. By the end of it I disagreed with almost everything I had said at the beginning and hated the comfy prospect of defining mysticism and analysing Maimonides' writings accordingly to fit into whatever I wanted him to say.

 Because it was not good enough, nothing I could say would do the man justice. So what was I doing?

And this is a problem with writing blogs in general. So much happens in the news, so many emotions are felt and by the time you get round to putting proverbial pen to paper you have changed your mind. 

The problem with wanting to change the world is simply that the only thing you can conceivably actively change it to is some vague imitation of yourself: 
'I wish school could inspire people to value education for its own sake!' 'Shutup Picasso, kids need to learn how to pay taxes and get a job. What you been smoking?' 

To accept that requires a humility that is not easily acquired - most people don't want what I want. Massive medieval Libraries and cricket statues in a castle resembling Hogwarts may seem like heaven to me but I think it would bewilder most other people.

So a few weeks ago I wrote down a few aphorisms that from my little red book of turning 25 as part of the need to feel important upon reaching the landmark; but as I sit here looking at them I have seen that they require heavy editing, but I'll try and leave most of them intact.


 Living in Brighton, I can't really call this Eastern wisdom. Maybe Southern wisdom. Or just Southern trains. Choo Choo.

On Judaism: Judaism will always require a mystical element for it to have any continued relevance to its adherents. No, not necessarily 'Jewish mysticism', much of which is not mystical at all but are simply pieces of information derived from sources considered mystical due to their vaguely kabbalistic and oooh coool connotations. 

I use mystical in the universal sense - that which treats God as real, tangible and important. Sephardim at prayer real. If being religious can ever mean something similar to attending a football match it will have done well. That is something that may have to be found in unexpected areas. 

Broadly speaking, in the modern world this requires a system of thinking that can encompass all Jewish areas of the universal and particular into a worldview that treats both as important. We cannot ignore our minds or our moral compasses, but if your idea of authentic Judaism is something that could have been copied and pasted from the Guardian last week, I'm not interested: Mr. Zeitgeist, go and party with your adherents. That's all I have to say about that. 

Truth be told, if you're unwilling to live in a bubble, experiencing this feeling can be bloody difficult.

On ideologies: You know, one problem I've always had with modernity is its flimsiness - here today gone tomorrow. This has also affected the way groups looking to 'change' things come across. Thou shalt love authenticity; brother. Religion shouldn't just be a social institution, it should be a pursuit of truth. 

The flip side of this is that you need to grapple honestly with issues that don't sit comfortably. If you can't find God in the Gemarah, look for Him elsewhere.

Whatever you think, just be nice about it. Whatever it is. Because it's not the be all and end all. Accept your inherent limitations. When death comes along or pain comes along and we forget our grandiose opinions in an instant anyway..


The 'meaning' of life: You can say meaning is 'made' not 'found' all day but you'll keep asking the question all the same. I think that we want there to be one point in life where we can turn around and say 'It's alright Ma, I made it'. 

The point of Academia: Still not entirely sure. To add to the sum of knowledge? Knowledge that no-one seems to access.

Right now I think it's to try and reassert the link between knowledge and goodness in society, to encourage a quest of discovery that empowers and enthuses the individual as mind and spirit combine in a relentless ascendant search for the ring of power. 

General 'self-help' thoughts (copyright: American publications, anytime between 1980 and now): Don't take anything too seriously, especially yourself. Be good to people regardless of their merits. Invest in personal relationships. Treat God like a relationship and be prepared to struggle, grapple and scratch your head. 


Expect little from human beings but believe in their potential. Because the masses are morons capable of great things. 


Time is best viewed cyclically: You are not the same as you were 1, 5, and 10 years ago. Don't feel guilty about that. Guilt achieves nothing. Just strap in and embrace the journey ahead with all the tools you've acquired. 

Don't preach to people too much about mistakes you've made that they should avoid, mistakes can be the best things you will ever do. Don't worry too much about the future. That old story of a climax and fall in your life, the 'best days of our lives'? Just an illusion. Things sucked then as they do now, you've just forgotten those bits. Be nostalgic about now - play pokemon, it helps. 


People should take flight as they wish; to discover, seek and explore. But you aren't born in a vacuum, don't know everything and someone is always more informed than you. Have humility to see beyond your cleverness. Truth can't be reduced to things you can measure in a lab, and if it could I wouldn't want it. But seek it nonetheless. 


Rock n roll. Keep on keeping on. Listen to Bob Dylan.
 

Friday, 8 July 2016

Sex abuse and the referendum: Us and them.




Us and them and after all we're only ordinary men. Pink Floyd.

A lot of things have happened over the last few weeks. 

 For the first time in my life I felt myself emotionally moved by politics, and also realised how strong certain feelings could spill into utter disdain for democracy and the ability of human beings to act wisely. But since then I've calmed down somewhat.

But far more harrowing that week was the breaking news of a scandal in the Jewish community where a sex abuser was retained as a capacity of rabbi by a number of institutions who ignored evidence of his conduct. 

It was particularly scary to read descriptions of his character: Controlling, making those around him emotionally dependant, living through them, crushing their confidence and lifting them out again. Without them realising. This resonated. I have experienced this type of character before, in my own life, and it is terrifying. 

But perhaps the issue that bothers me most comes down to these three words: Us and Them. 

We, the English. We want control of our money, our country, our laws, our people, our heritage. They the foreigners, they the immigrants, they the Europeans. Let them burn. The attitude scares me as a Jew and as a human being. 

Yes, I'm sure some used their calculators to argue that they will in the long term have more cash somehow but the number of slogans and comments suggesting otherwise leads me to think that this was not the only issue at hand.

And you never ask questions when God's on your side. Bob Dylan.

Us, the religious people, us in possession of truth and insight, we the select. When the whole concept of being religious is thought about exclusively in terms of knowledge of texts, Judaism is whatever the rabbi says it is as he's the expert, and Judaism covers all areas of life, he must be right. Or we must protect him as he must have just taken things a bit 'too far' but is essentially well meaning.

Do you see how easy it is to pretend that everything is ok?

You can make all the checks and supervision you want but once you're on the inside it's very hard to take a look at a situation from the outside. Changing attitudes that are so deeply ingrained would seem to some as an impossible struggle. When it's us and them you don't think about much beyond the walls of your mind. 

The tragedy in Israel recently only serves to galvanise this sort of attitude, and clearly I can't blame anyone for thinking that but... Us and them Us and them. Us and them.  

Reading this back, it looks like I have great anger towards being religious. I don't. I love being religious. 
But I used to think that insularity was a personality type or a lifestyle choice. 
But increasingly I see it as dangerous and dark. 
Us...
and them?

Friday, 3 June 2016

Is there virtue in being ignorant? Donald Trump as the main reason not to live in a big ivory tower.



In general, I find politics to be juvenile and irritating. But recently this sense of irritation has spread to the thing I spend my days most involved in, typing away on a laptop: Academia and education. At times it feels very hollow and incomplete. What do I mean? I mean that the message it generally promotes is either to make money or serve the lofty aim of being a valuable 'thing in itself''.

Sometimes I think of the rise of Trump as being the product of the utter failure of western education to have any significant impact upon the 'real' lives of 'real' people. 

I do not mean in terms of subject material, either. It is the process of education as much as the result of it that is important. Education should broaden the mind to allow you to view the world from multiple perspectives and understand where other people are coming from. Not only from a rationalistic standpoint but also in terms of human empathy.

This should be its purpose, and whilst obviously no system can account for all the quirks of human beings, it should at the very least bring to attention the ridiculousness of brazen extremes. It should, at the very least, teach you that the world is a complex place which requires a degree of caution before you are convinced of your own rightness or are persuaded by slogans. Apologies for the dismissive arrogance of my tone.

Academics in the humanities and social sciences  thrive on writing about issues that are self-contained to the extent that not only do normal people have no idea what they are talking about but that only a select few in their subject area do either. There is too often no relationship with other areas of thought and no attempt to make that jump to consider how to improve society or even to attempt to understand it better or even to dwell upon how a given topic relates to themselves as human beings.

The ultimate sign of intelligence remains financial success or the ability to express yourself unclearly. 'Truth' and 'facts' are just word games. 

The compartmentalisation of knowledge means that very few are able to achieve the next step: wisdom. And, with the ridiculousness of the American situation (not to mention Israeli politics) it would be nice to have a bit more of that in our society.

Take Richard Dawkins, for example; brilliant mind who regularly makes crude and hysterical statements that do not even attempt to understand a perspective beyond his own. To avoid accusations of religious prejudice I have often extended the same accusation to people involved in the rabbinate.

I had an entertaining example of this the other week, where a Frum guest spoke in Brighton synagogue about the great evils of women dressing inappropriately and how this is the worst spiritual generation that there has ever been. Yes, in Brighton. Laughing at the ridiculousness of his inability to ahem read his audience and also by the fact that such a scripted line remains compelling to a man in his fifties, I remembered that these exact sentiments could be communicated in a Yeshiva environment and no-one would bad an eyelid. 

There are many people out there, hiding in their broom cupboards with a wealth of knowledge and deep understanding to share; and yet, like the volumes they pore over, they fade into the dust and most people don't know any better. Instead, the headlines are dominated by the boorish statements of a rich tycoon and the angry prattle of indignant people on twitter, feeling very offended. 

Ah well, the sabbath beckons, off to return to my commune.

 .


Thursday, 21 April 2016

Are we trapped by hearing the same messages of freedom every year?





Tolling for the rebel, tolling for the rake
Tolling for the luckless, the abandoned an’ forsaked
Tolling for the outcast, burnin’ constantly at stake
An’ we gazed upon the chimes of freedom flashing

'Chimes of Freedom' Bob Dylan. 


The idea of freedom implies an ability to be able to control our lives without external hardships preventing us from doing so, but it is also a passionate cry of hope:


Freedom of expression, freedom of religion, freedom of information. 


Often closely linked with equality, all these 'freedoms' look towards a future that is better than the present, given the access to what is being requested.

But what that means is never quite clear. 
Once one freedom is realised others will be sought. Freedom chimed in the sixties, everyone became disillusioned again in the 70s, God blessed America and fat corporations in the 80s and 90s Internet came along in the noughties and now in the noughteens it thinks for us. 


So, Pesach 2016, what does freedom mean in a religious sense?Generally, one of two things. Option 1. Freedom to serve God.


Hmm Re-defining the term and not exactly an explanation of how this is achieved so bit too much lip service there.

 Option 2. Self liberation. Certainly an admirable idea. Break out of self-imposed limits. Good message.

But it becomes frustrating when it is the only thing said again and again, without questioning whether thinking on such an introspective level a. is useful for everyone b. whether it is a helpful message or c. just boxes us into narrow thoughts without thinking about the wider community?

 Whilst the chagim/festivals can at times be spiritually revitalising at other times the cyclical concept of time seems like an endless merry-go-round. I struggle hearing the same things too often so I try and find different ways to look at these messages.  

My own quest thoughts about freedom over Pesach is closely related to how I understand personal creativity and dynamism and how that struggles to express itself in a community framework. 


Many of the people I know with the most interesting perspectives on life feel no relationship whatsoever with the Orthodox communities that surround them, even if they are nominally involved. 

How do we, as Jews, create a society which is both loyal, traditional, spontaneous and dynamic - and how do we get people to want such a society? Why is it that institutions that associate with 'frumkeit' tend to be one dimensional, boring and fail to appeal beyond a certain age? 

This is something that Nathan Lopez Cardozo constantly talks about in his blogposts (Thank you Michael for showing me his latest one) and I used to never pay much attention to but increasingly it is a message that resonates.

From some of my own experiences of 'outreach' organisations who share this vision, there can be a quite blatant manipulation towards a particular, very specific agenda,  and the list of jaded participants is long and depressing. 

To keep this short I will share two corporate-sounding suggestions: Need and empowerment.  People feel invested when they feel needed. But not just needed as a body to turn up to an event to make up a number but as an individual with their own mad ideas, appreciated for their own oddness. 

People in leadership are not always the best listeners, even if you feel listened to, and simply communicate their conviction about the rightness of their position. It helps if you are clever, loud and slightly arrogant.

So let's empower, somehow, and listen to what people think and have to say about the world. Risk it, and we might set ourselves free.       


 

  


Monday, 4 April 2016

Drunken Jews: Two hours of optimism, once a year



May you build a ladder to the stars, climb on every rung, may you stay forever young. 

Purim, forgive the pun, can be a very sobering experience (This is a bit late, admittedly). Whilst explanations for inebriation on the day range from expanding God-awareness and exposing a profound inner world to blurring the lines of reality to see the hidden nature of God in history, the reality is usually far more mundane. Nevertheless it has one quality that stands out which remains longer than the hangover the next day: optimism.

More than any other festival, under the boozy haze scattered with flashes of religious sentiment, this message shines through: No matter how bad things get, things will get better and there is always hope. Not for any particular reason, but because God runs the world even if we do not see it.

This is not just a message of Purim but is also expressed in the unusual bonds of solidarity that the festival helps to cultivate. People who never normally speak to each other become best friends, talking and laughing together. Under the cloud of inebriation, people forget their social differences and there is a general feeling that the world can be transformed for better but also not to dwell too much on the negative aspects of this world. 

But then tomorrow comes, and like most other inspiring experiences, fades away. Ten days later, it has already disappeared over the horizon. But it asks a question of those who claim to be religious, particularly in the aftermath of the terrible terrorist attacks that occurred a few days before Purim: 

Do we honestly feel optimism about the future? One of the great qualities of faith, one that I and I'm sure many others struggle with, is the ability to incorporate negative life experiences into a positive, transformative mindset to persevere regardless of the consequences. 

And it is one that I question whether the Jewish world is particularly good at. Anti-Semitism and anti-Israel issues are certainly real and need addressing but must they dominate in such a prominent manner? I recall a facebook post by a particular rabbi during a time of rocket fire telling people off for trivial posts during a time of attack but is this a useful, helpful or positive way to see the world? Sometimes it seems that on a public level, protest against problems actually gets in the way of cultivating a vibrant and positive attitude to the world. Fear, guilt and indignation can become crutches that we lean upon in religious life to the extent that we can't imagine life without them.

Purim doesn't necessarily teach us that things will get better tomorrow but it does provide a useful antidote against despair about the world around us. We would do well, as Dylan prayed for his newborn sung, to try to stay forever young.      






Friday, 18 March 2016

View from the seafront: An Orthodox Jew Living in Brighton, far away from the big city



'You're going to Brighton?!' The question was often posed as if I was leaving for Siberia. Alternatively: 'That's so brave of you!' or 'Are you ok for food?' as if we had been stranded on a desert island with an occasional ferry sailing past for essential supplies.

Well surprisingly, the distance between Hove and Kosher Kingdom has proved to be less painful than many had expected. And it has helped me observe several things about community life.

About 18 months ago I wrote a blog about why I loved living Manchester and how community life was much more to do with friendliness than outlook but I would like to add another element to that: Need. In small communities everyone is needed so everyone is important. Not for their intelligence or for a function they perform but simply for existing. Everyone is therefore invested in the project of community building and it becomes part of their own personal identity. I could be wrong but I also think this mutual dependence helps people become nicer to each other.  

In Brighton, for instance, if one of the regulars doesn't turn up on Mondays and Thursdays we don't get a Minyan. In Hendon if you don't turn up for a year of Mondays and Thursdays it's unlikely that anyone would notice. Maybe it's the difference between living in a big city and not but I find that the idea of community matters much more to me in Brighton than it did in London. In addition, the small University J-Soc is not simply a means for Jews to pretend they can take their drink, it becomes an important part of community life. 

Jews like to live in big cities. Bigger is usually seen to be better. 'London? There's a big community there no? A good community.' 'New York? It's practically Jewish!' But cities also tend to be loud, impatient and very expensive. Jerusalem is paradise right? Well, not if you don't like lots of traffic and noise. As subversive as that sounds. 

There are actually many advantages of leaving the big city; for one, it allows you to slow down a bit. See nature, and yes, even get in touch with God a bit more - it is much harder to pay Him any mind in the concrete jungle. For another, comfort zones can be very stagnant. Humans like to be creative and strive for an impact in this world. 

Instead of fretting over the prospect of living in a place where pre-checked lettuce isn't readily available, perhaps leaving our comfort zones helps us invest much more strongly in our values and identity and develop in new, unforseen ways? In fact, I would recommend travel as a healthy alternative to intensive Kiruv seminars as a means of reconnecting with your identity (bring books with as well). And by travel I don't mean going to Thailand on drunken holidays. 

Whilst conventional wisdom sympathised with the Hendon boy forced to leave his mama behind for his wife's degree in Sussex, I was excited about the prospect of leaving North West London. It was a bit like a call to action and a guarantee that I would be valued regardless of what I did or accomplished.   

And one last thing: 'Aren't there only old people there?' Yes, but they usually have much more to teach you about life than young people. So come along to the south coast, you might just be pleasantly surprised!  

Friday, 4 March 2016

Arsene Wenger and what Arsenal teaches us about history





For an Arsenal fan, it's been the same for the last 12 years. The expectation, the anticipation, the inevitable disappointment. The one player left standing alone on the pitch who has carried our hopes for the season, frustrated and helpless. The same advice is thrown about every year: Buy, spend more, build a squad. After a few weeks the hype dies and no-one of significance is added. Back to the youtube videos of Bergkamp and Henry, remembering the good old days at the turn of the century. We never seem to learn.

Maybe we just can't learn from the past? But I refuse to accept this position. The reason I believe we can is that our collective knowledge is not incremental. Whilst in science and medicine, change has been consistently improving (even if for sometimes random reasons), it is mistaken to think this applies to the rest of life. Are we happier, more fulfilled and better people than those who lived 500, 1000 years ago? It doesn't seem so. Not that things are necessarily worse now, that would be equally misleading to suggest, but that it seems that each era has its thing, its area of strength that gets forgotten by subsequent generations.

I often think that when I go into a library. It hits you - there are thousands and thousands of books here, how many have people actually read? How much of their knowledge and insight is lost forever? Has internet access made us wiser or simply lazier? 

In studying rabbis who lived around the time of what is known as the 'Renaissance' period, I have encountered the idea of using history and find it fascinating to apply to our own society. Renaissance literature, architecture and paintings were geared around a vision for the betterment of the world based on learning from the knowledge of the ancients, a general optimism about the role of man in the world and his ability to spread values that would improve society. Knowledge wasn't simply for the elites in the academy, it served a broader purpose. One theory went, that by looking and living around things of beauty which promoted good values and ideals, society would become a more peaceful, moral and harmonious place. Paintings of classic Christian figures stopped looking austere and frightening and started looking human and compassionate. 

Buildings in Italian cities are brilliantly symmetrical, with arches and courtyards, with many 16th century books written on how architecture should be designed to enable, for example, a mother to shout out a window to her child playing outside so he could hear.  

This is just one important lesson we can find in historical annals, the power of both the visual and emotional stimuli to envision a better society. So as an Arsenal fan I look back to Dennis Bergkamp, Robert Pires and the gang and remember the days when beauty and success went hand in hand. 

The Jewish world has been enormously affected by the Enlightenment and the triumph of Science and reason in the 18th and 19th Centuries. Even today, many discussions are framed in terms of the rational as opposed to the irrational in religion. But it hasn't really developed a renaissance-like mindset in the same way - there was not a movement comparable to the one in the Christian world (not an unconstested view). It was clearly more difficult when we were a minority with little financial independence but it would be an interesting question as to whether some of the more romantic and idealistic conceptions of the past using visual media could be appropriated by Jewish leaders in their visions of building a more harmonious Jewish society.

Friday, 26 February 2016

Car Journeys from hell: Can we enjoy life without guilt?



Have you ever turned around and felt that guilt is far too dominant as a basis for religious life? I believe it is a product of the compartmentalised book mindset I discussed last week. The following story is a case in point from one of the most awkward car journey moments I have ever had:

It happened about four years ago; two of my friends and I were in a car with a particular rabbi, animatedly discussing an issue that bothered us about our responsibilities in Jewish outreach. All three of us were very passionate about the subject and enjoyed the opportunity to address these issues with someone older, wiser and more experienced. But at one point the rabbi stopped and turned to us with the following question: Well, we've discussed that topic - now what's everyone been learning - do you have a sefer to learn from or a D'var Torah? 

The three of is froze, awkwardly. We stayed silent for about thirty seconds. Slowly, I produced a book that I happened to be carrying and started reading, agonisingly, for about ten minutes. It was awkward, painstaking and completely artificial. The rabbi smiled indulgently whilst the three of us sat there feeling mildly humiliated and guilty. The subtext was clear: "You're frum, you should be discussing words of Torah. If you aren't, you're not doing very well are you?". The perfect guilt trip and an illuminating window into the minds of our teachers.

This story has stuck in the mind as the thing that irritates me most about how most informed and educated people understand religious observance and their inability to see it holistically. 

But I must approach this with a degree of humility. Perhaps I am not correct; perhaps every action I do does need to be based upon an underlying basis to be considered appropriately religious, a means to an ends. It may not be enough to enjoy something and I may think along these lines as a form of self-legitimisation. But it raises lots of questions:

For example, even in the minds of those who associate with the 'Modern Orthodox' mindset, is personal development a religious end in itself or only inasmuch as it makes me go to shul more, pray with more concentration or learn more Torah?

This week's parasha reminds me of this point. On the one hand, we have the golden calf - condemned as the deceptive intermediary between man and God, preventing the pure relationship between God and His people. In sermons this is often extended to all material goods and pleasures - be careful not to make them into a golden calf. But it is also interesting to read the ornate descriptions of the mishkan and the garments of the Kohen that surrounds this parasha. I know the discussions surrounding the relationship between the two but what if people forgot to make the link between lofty elevation of divine service and the nice shiny looking objects? They might have had an off day and then it's cow time again. Shouldn't that be avoided too?

 Sanctify the mundane for holy purposes but don't let it escalate - a very thin line. It leads me to something I have thought about a lot recently: Does Judaism require me to link everything I value directly to God or not? Could I gaze at the garments of the Kohen, for example, dazzled by their splendour and enjoy their beauty or would I need to say - Wow, what an amazing creation of God's? 

It is the question of whether God can or should be found in the immediate situation and experience you are encountering even if it is not directly linked to Him. Is it enough to be happy, interested, joyful or grateful? Are these positive, life enhancing sensations inherently Godly? Because personally I think that if they are not, the 'means to an ends' doesn't work very well and guilt will prevail. And if they are they should be discussed far more. 

You see, when you go off to work or university thinking that the primary expression of being religious is the active involvement with a gemarah or a positive fulfilment of commandment x or y then the following scenario will occur time and time again, and it has nothing necessarily to do with the great appeal of the outside world or its temptations: 

You start by happily thinking along the lines you have been taught: Look forward to the mincha, to the learning later, to the providing of a parnassah for your family. But then you find that you begin to enjoy other things. Things that don't seem prohibited but that don't seem obviously religious. Maybe it is the work, the social interaction with colleagues or just being involved in a Jewish society at University... 

 Then a little gremlin taps you on your shoulder saying: Shouldn't you be learning? Are you doing this for the right reasons ie. so that you can sustain something else which is actually important? Yes, that makes this important by extension but it doesn't feel that way. It becomes a competition for attention between 'you' as you see yourself and 'you' as you are supposed to want to be. Some would call it cheshbon ha nefesh. Others would say it's a lifetime guilt trip. Something's gonna give and guess what? It's rarely the thing you actually enjoy.
 And somewhere along the way, the music starts to fade. Because God is only found in the 'other' thing.

In future posts I would like to link this discussion to the topic of 'Shleimut' or 'completeness' found in the writings of medieval and early modern Jewish writers linked to an ideal of personal development very similar to that found in renaissance thought. 

Wednesday, 17 February 2016

Why books make you foolish: Lessons from Harry Potter.


'Never trust something if you don't know where it keeps its brain'. In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets *SPOILER* Arthur Weasley reprimands his daughter Ginny for allowing herself to be lured into writing to an invisible stranger within a diary who turned out to be the young Lord Voldemort. Voldemort ended up possessing Ginny and were it not for Harry and Ron's heroics, would not have lived to tell the tale.

In studying Jewish texts we often don't know the brain behind the books or particularly care, either. If we study a work of halacha, a view and discussion is presented detached from life, background and personality of the people who wrote it. Some argue that this doesn't matter, it is the points that count. But to me it does - particularly when we take life lessons from the books. 

How do we translate words from a page into daily life that we experience at every given moment? If we take the words too literally we can find them utterly disconnected from anything that we experience in our own lives and it is this problem that I believe lies at the heart of much rabbinic and religious leadership today - an inability to understand two domains simultaneously: The penetrating, careful and loyal engagement with our religious texts and a deep understanding of real human life; the ability to see both domains as crucial to a vibrant religious existence.

What do I mean? In Judaism our books are the source of our wisdom. Many sermons will start along the lines of : 'It says in Sefer/book x, Gemarah y etc.' But quoting a book will never enable us to gauge the human life element lying behind the words. We know that life is ever-changing, dynamic, complex and can not be reduced to a list of words. How God relates to our ups, downs and hurts can't be read to us dispassionately from a list of sources, irrespective of their sanctity.

I have noticed the disconnect between 'book world' and 'real world' when rabbis or speakers make a generalising joke about women or gay people for example, which makes many of the congregants cringe uneasily. Jokes and attitudes that were acceptable twenty years ago are off-colour today. To be truly respected by people you have to understand how they think and feel. 

It may not bother them in the slightest, 'The rabbi was controversial today? Oooh what did he say? etc.' But it shows something is missing in that we have placed religion in a compartment reserved for the texts associated with it - as long as he can tell us if our pans are kosher we'll keep him, as long as he gives a good gemarah shiur etc. The book is there but where is it's brain?

The issue here is that it shows that the rabbi, who represents Judaism, is a figure who isn't associated by his community as possessing a mature understanding of human beings or society.

Too often it seems that the connection between a deep understanding of ourselves, of our place in the world and our relationship with God through the Torah is hidden rather than magnified by teachers educated in the (usually) Yeshivish world of books. Quotes - tick. Knowledge of religious material - tick. Wisdom? Insight? That's for the psychologists, for the famous scientists, maybe  a particularly kind of one-in-a-million rabbi who writes famous books and does world tours. Or alternatively, 'Go and look in a mussar book for that or listen to Kiruv rabbi x!'. 

Sources, sources. We love our sources. Text-based shiurim are contrasted to airy-fairy fluff. But sources are only as insightful as the one reading them, and  the extent they can grasp the concepts and relate them to the broader understanding of where the source is coming from. There is so much 'Rabbi x said this Rabbi y said that' that we act as though the whole life of that person can be summarised by a line that they may have written (probably misquoted and out of context) in a book somewhere. 

But we know that if we were in the same position and that's all people thought about our lives we would be very disappointed. It would be like building a profile of ourselves from our text messages or tweets. Sometimes its better to put the books down before we lose ourselves too much in a world built entirely of them. Otherwise we may end up speaking to Voldemort and not even realise it.

Thursday, 11 February 2016

Should we take anything seriously? The ability to laugh at ourselves

WHY SO SERIOUS?     THE JOKER

Among Dylan's unique traits apart from being one of about ten people in the last fifty years to be able to write half-decent lyrics was the contempt he showed for journalists. Whenever he was asked about the deeper meaning of his songs he would laugh, smoke a cigarette and reply "I don't know man, you tell me what they mean".

 When one of the lefty-intellectual types mentioned something he had come up with as a suggestion or interpretation for what an album might symbolise,  Dylan just looked mildly amused and condescendingly congratulated him for his insight: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=guOaI6_cF10

 Whether this makes him the nicest person in the world is besides the point; he couldn't stand how seriously they were taking everything he said. He could laugh at himself. It was a bit ridiculous after all, for every self proclaimed intellectual to use this 'song and dance man' as their icon and hero.

Fast forward fifty years and I find that the only people I find myself wanting to talk to about 'serious' issues are those who don't mind laughing at themselves, as if to say 'yes, who really cares, I could be completely wrong and am a slightly ridiculous person just like the rest of the world'. 

Then I can respect them. Because I can see that they have the humility to realise that they are just one person and that there are many views on a particular subject. This shouldn't mean that they should not be passionate, but that it should not escalate to the point where everyone else can be presumed wrong. No this isn't a punt for pluralism. Pluralists are amongst the internet's biggest zealots. It is about a mindset that should precede the expressing of an opinion. 

For me, it would be the equivalent of 'I am self-indulgently writing another blog quoting quite pretentious sources left, right and centre under the pretence of some sort of authority' - a sort of leshem yichud before each blogpost ( in-joke, sorry).

 I admired a Chabad rabbi who I spoke to recently when he replied to a question of mine by stating that 'Yes, you could see it from another angle, but I am presenting the chabad position on the matter' - I respect that. He could see that his way wasn't the only way but it was the one he believed was true. 

Because most conversations about religion and politics are had by those who really think they have a personal right to be listened to. Particularly with these areas, the atmosphere can become bigoted or hostile, or alternatively lots of like-minded people find a strawman to bash e.g. the chareidim or the open orthodox and inevitable schisms in Orthodoxy.

Well, you could turn around and say, of course you have to take these things seriously - sometimes these are matters of life and death or the welfare of individuals and society, these are serious issues. Agreed. They are serious issues. But you getting all serious about them is not going to resolve them any better and will probably mean that they are less likely to get addressed because once you take the 'I'm the serious one' position you have essentially blocked off one side of the argument. 

It's like the whole political correctness nonsense that now pervades every University campus. The issues that are debated are all about the feelings and rights of every possible group and minority who might be offended and whilst this is admirable if it prevents persecution it can also become completely intellectually stultifying. You are so busy worried about how many things might offend people that no-one's knowledge is broadened or expanded on any topic whatsoever. It's also no fun. 

Parroted words about 'discourse' and 'spaces' and 'conversations' replace challenge and debate. I would know. When I went to a school that wasn't Jewish, I had many conversations about religion which were not always comfortable, and which I didn't always know how to respond. But who cares? chill out! Learn a bit more, explore a bit more, maybe leave your comfort zone. Rome wasn't build in a day, ho ho.  Either way, I often wonder if the world would be a better place if world leaders looked in the mirror and said to themselves "Which idiot put me in charge of a whole country?"

Tuesday, 2 February 2016

Why do we remember? Memorials, silences and where no words can be said.



Yosef Hayyim Yerushalmi wrote a book compiling his essays on the subject of Judaism and memory in 1982; in it, he argued that academic scholarship and historical 'truth' have been disconnected from popular memory since the 19th Century. Up till then, Judaism saw history as a grand divine narrative, starting with Adam and culminating in the Moshiach. The passage of time was never seen as relevant apart from its religious meaning. Wars, plagues and tragedies were seen as essentially the same thing - a reminder from God to repent. But after the nineteenth century when secular scholars began placing historical events in their own context, the history of religion and the academic scholar permanently divided.

Amos Fukenstein critiqued this position by suggesting that a. It is difficult to describe a people as remembering in one particular way, individuals remember not people ( a classic postmodern critique which is then qualified by mentioning that there can still be many shared traditions and experiences) and this has varied over the centuries with Rambam and renaissance thinkers having more of a 'realist' view of history 2. The German Academics of the 19th century were also writing for a Jewish audience with similar aspirations to themselves, to become emancipated, enlightened and universalist in nature. They shared the popular mindset of the Reformers. 

But the overall point remains strong: In classical Jewish sources until the 19th century, the importance of remembering is how to respond to God's signs in history. It is a call to action or a call to repentance. During our fast days which are held on days commemorating a tragedy, we are not told to analyse the details of the day - the kinnot are fairly thin in historical detail - but rather to cry out to our father in heaven for repentance. Memorials and silences out of respect might cause introspection but they do not contain the implication that we must or can do something about this memory. 

But then comes Holocaust memorial day. The most difficult of topics to think about. In fact, one of the reasons I have avoided studying modern history is because I simply cannot grasp the enormity of the holocaust in a way which comes close to being detached (Not that any scholar is ever completely detached from their sources but there is definitely a spectrum).

The academic, prosaic mindset can't grasp it. Perhaps here are the borders of scholarship, where data and interpretation must concede that they can go no further. Here, in my opinion, is also an excellent example of the tension between traditional religion and modernity. 

Many in the chareidi/ frum world have given speeches over the years about how the ignorant 'secularist' Israeli government insist on making another Shoah day whilst ignoring Tish'a B'Av. The Jewish position, they say with some justification, would be to place the holocaust in the overall narrative of Jewish suffering in history. 

But to the modern mind, the indiscriminate systematic and comprehensive evil of the Shoah cannot be simply placed in a system which seems to lay blame on its victims. It can never be justified or understood by adding it to a religious narrative of history, as if this explains it. It cannot be seen as part of something else. To give explanations that focus on punishment seems so short-sighted, cruel and foolish. 

And yet religion is significant only to the extent that the individual can have a personal, intimate and unmediated relationship with the divine. A God who loves us.
The mind has reached its limits. Silence now. 

Thinking back to various figures who either directly or implicitly told us that we had a duty to do something to preserve the memories of those who were murdered, perhaps you didn't understand that sometimes no words can be said. That sometimes the lessons you taught are cheap and cruelly manipulative and stab us with pangs of guilt. Perhaps you should have stayed silent about that which you cannot speak. 

Perhaps I can conclude in my own mind that although as a Jew painful collective memories must be used to stir us to action, sometimes it is up to us to decide the relationship between that memory and our action, for to draw links between the two implying a causal relationship assumes an omniscience that I nor any other human being can ever have.